Rww. Hsu et al., HYBRID TOTAL KNEE ARTHROPLASTY - A 3 TO 6-YEAR OUTCOME ANALYSIS, Journal of the Formosan Medical Association, 97(6), 1998, pp. 410-415
We retrospectively analyzed the outcomes of hybrid total knee arthropl
asty (TKA) with Miller Galante I (MG I) prostheses in 113 consecutive
patients (140 knees). The mean follow-up period was 4.8 years (range 3
.2-6.6). There were 135 cases of osteoarthritis and five of rheumatoid
arthritis. The average age of patients at the time of surgery was 62.
6) ears. The Hospital for Special Surgery knee score along with radiog
raphs were used to evaluate preoperative and postoperative knee status
, and the Cybex isokinetic test,vas used to assess muscle strength at
the final follow-up. The average knee score improved from 64 points pr
eoperatively to 90 points postoperatively (p < 0.05). The mean motion
are of the knee improved from 108 degrees preoperatively to 116 degree
s at the final evaluation. A total of 122 knees were pain free on walk
ing and 130 knees were completely pain free at rest. A total of 134 kn
ees achieved good to excellent clinical results. The radiographic resu
lts shelved that the mechanical asis of the lower extremity was realig
ned from a mean of 12 degrees varus preoperatively to 3.mean of 1 degr
ees varus postoperatively. So obvious radiolucent zones were found on
the lateral view of the femoral components in 60.7% of the knees, or o
n the anteroposterior or lateral views around the tibial components in
49.3% and 82.9% of knees, respectively. The Cybex isokinetic test at
the final follow-up examination revealed that the hamstring:; quadrice
ps peak torque ratio was 0.8 at a speed of 60 degrees per second and 0
.96 at 180 degrees per second, indicating that quadriceps muscle stren
gth did not recover to within the range of healthy subjects. There wer
e 23 (16.4%) complications, including polyethylene wear of patellar co
mponents (14), patellofemoral maltracking (4), septic loosening (2), a
septic loosening (2), and superficial infection (1). Revision surgery
improved the functional outcomes in all of these knees. Based on our e
xperience, we do not recommend the use of the MG I prosthesis in total
knee arthroplasty (TKA) because of the high rate of patellar complica
tions. Strengthening of the quadriceps must be emphasized in postopera
tive rehabilitation. Hybrid fixation might be a useful alternative fix
ation mode in TKA procedures.