Focusing on a religious commune known as the Shakers and utilizing the
information recorded in the enumeration schedules of the U.S. manufac
turing and agriculture censuses, this article estimates the productivi
ties of Shaker enterprises and compares them with those of other produ
cers randomly selected from the same data source. The results provide
support to the contention that communes need not always suffer from re
duced productivity. Shaker farms and shops generally performed just as
productively as their neighbors; when differences did exist between t
heir productivities, there are good reasons to attribute them to facto
rs other than the organizational form.