Rf. Martell et al., SEX STEREOTYPING IN THE EXECUTIVE SUITE - MUCH ADO ABOUT SOMETHING, Journal of social behavior and personality, 13(1), 1998, pp. 127-138
Studies of how managerial women are perceived in the workplace, as com
pared with men, have been concerned mostly with entry and middle level
s of management. Surprisingly, little attention has been directed to w
hether men and women are perceived differently on the attributes assoc
iated with successful executives (vice-president level and above). To
address this question, an inventory comprised of attributes deemed cha
racteristic of successful executives was first constructed. Principal
components analysis identified four key factors underlying the executi
ve attribute inventory. Next, the inventory was completed by 132 male
managers, each of whom rated one of four target groups: women middle m
anagers, men middle managers, successful women middle managers, or suc
cessful men middle managers. Results revealed sex differences (always
favoring men) on all but the Results-Oriented factor. When depicted as
middle managers, women were rated less favorably than men on the Chan
ge Agent, Managerial Courage, and Leadership factors. When depicted as
successful middle managers, sex differences were eliminated only on t
he Leadership factor ratings. These findings support the ''lack of fit
'' explanation for the current dearth of women executives and suggest
that the ''pipeline'' explanation is overly optimistic.