M. Roberts et al., ORAL VACCINATION AGAINST TETANUS - COMPARISON OF THE IMMUNOGENICITIESOF SALMONELLA STRAINS EXPRESSING FRAGMENT-C FROM THE NIRB AND HTRA PROMOTERS, Infection and immunity, 66(7), 1998, pp. 3080-3087
We have found the in vivo-regulated nirB promoter (P-nirB) to be effec
tive for directing expression of a number of antigens in salmonella in
vivo. We wished to determine if other in vivo-regulated promoters hav
e utility for antigen expression in salmonella and to compare the effe
ctiveness of these promoters with that of P-nirB. To this end, we have
devised a scheme that allows the promoter element of the P-nirB-fragm
ent C plasmid pTETnir15 to be swapped with other promoters of interest
. We demonstrate the usefulness of this system by replacing P-nirB wit
h P-htrA to create plasmid pTEThtrA1. htrA is a stress response gene t
hat is required for virulence of salmonella in mice and survival withi
n macrophages. Expression of fragment C in Salmonella typhimurium BRD5
09 (aroA aroD) harboring pTEThtrA1 (strain BRD937) correlated with gro
wth temperature in vitro. A comparison was made of the immune response
s to fragment C elicited in mice immunized orally with BRD937 or BRD83
7 (BRD509/pTETnir15) or subcutaneously with purified fragment C plus a
lhydrogel. High levels of anti-fragment C antibodies that persisted fo
r at least 12 weeks were present in all groups of mice. Vaccination wi
th BRD937 was the most effective means of immunization: the serum immu
noglobulin G (IgG), IgA, and IgM anti-fragment C titers were higher in
the BRD937-immunized mice throughout the duration of the study than i
n mice in the other groups. The kinetics of the serum anti-fragment C
responses were different in different groups. The response was most ra
pid in the BRD937 group, with the titers almost at peak levels at 2 we
eks postimmunization. Only the mice immunized with BRD937 or BRD837 de
veloped an intestinal IgA response to fragment C. Again, the response
was superior in the BRD937 group. The peak of the intestinal response
was delayed with respect to the serum response. Analysis of the Ige su
btype response to fragment C revealed a dominant IgG2a response in the
salmonella-immunized mice, indicating a type 1 helper T-cell response
to fragment C, whereas the major subtype in the group parenterally im
munized with fragment C plus alhydrogel was IgG1. The IgG1/IgG2a ratio
was much higher in sera of BRD937-immunized mice than in sera of BRD8
47-immunized mice. At 15 to 20,weeks after immunization, the mice immu
nized with BRD937 or BRD817 were solidly immune to tetanus toxin and s
almonella. The immune responses to fragment C seen in mice immunized w
ith BRD937 are the strongest,ve have observed and indicate that the ht
rA promoter may be very useful for expressing foreign antigens in salm
onella vaccine strains.