Rk. Woods et al., THE EFFECTS OF MONOSODIUM GLUTAMATE IN ADULTS WITH ASTHMA WHO PERCEIVE THEMSELVES TO BE MONOSODIUM GLUTAMATE-INTOLERANT, Journal of allergy and clinical immunology, 101(6), 1998, pp. 762-771
Background: Many previous clinical studies of food-induced asthma suff
er from inadequate baseline or control data. A statistically valid, ra
ndomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, monosodium glutamate (MSG)
-challenge protocol was developed for identifying early and late asthm
atic reactions in an individual.Objective: We sought to determine whet
her MSG would induce bronchoconstriction in a group of adults with ast
hma who perceived that they were MSG sensitive. Methods: Twelve subjec
ts (seven women, mean age 35.3 years) with clinically documented asthm
a and a perception of MSG-induced asthma were recruited. FEV1 and peak
expiratory flow data were obtained for 3 whole control days, as well
as time-matched data for 3 separate challenge days (1 gm MSG, 5 gm MSG
, and 5 gm lactose [placebo]). Opaque capsule challenges were given as
a single dose in the morning after an overnight fast. Subjects compli
ed with atl elimination diet throughout the study. Nonspecific bronchi
al hyperresponsiveness was measured at baseline, after the control day
s, and at the conclusion of the challenges. Venous blood samples were
taken at baseline and on each challenge day to determine soluble infla
mmatory marker (eosinophil cationic protein and tryptase) activity. Re
sults: No immediate or definite late asthmatic reactions occurred. One
subject's FEV1 declined more than 15% on MSG challenge, but 95% confi
dence limits for the control-day spirometry showed that this decline w
as within her daily variation, hence the challenge was deemed to be ne
gative. No significant changes in bronchial hyperresponsiveness or sol
uble inflammatory markers were found. Conclusions: MSG induced asthma
was not demonstrated in this study. This study highlighted the importa
nce of adequate baseline and control data and indicated that such a ri
gorous protocol for individual assessment is feasible.