Ks. Hone et al., SPEECH TECHNOLOGY FOR AUTOMATIC TELLER MACHINES - AN INVESTIGATION OFUSER ATTITUDE AND PERFORMANCE, Ergonomics, 41(7), 1998, pp. 962-981
Despite the success and widespread use of Automatic Teller Machines (A
TMs), a significant proportion of bank customers can not or will not u
se them, or experience difficulties in their interactions. Speech tech
nology has been suggested as a means by which non-users might be encou
raged to use ATMs, while simultaneously improving usability for all. T
he potential advantages of speech interfaces include hands-free and ey
es-free use for physically- and visually-impaired users, and improved
ease and speed of use through increased 'naturalness' of the interacti
on. This study investigated user attitudes to the concepts of a speech
-based ATM, via large-scale survey and a series of focus groups. Objec
tive performance was also considered in user trials with a prototype s
peech-driven ATM. The idea of using speech for ATM transactions led to
a number of concerns. Privacy (the concern over one's personal financ
ial details being overheard) and security (the fear of potential attac
kers hearing the user withdraw cash) were the major reasons given. The
user trials confirmed that possible solutions, such as the adoption o
f a hood over the ATM or the use of a telephone handset as the speech
input/output device, were ineffective. Groups of impaired users, parti
cularly visually-impaired subjects, were more positive about the conce
pt of speech, citing various difficulties with current visual-manual i
nteractions. Most non-users, however, would not be encouraged to use A
TMs with the addition of speech. The paper discusses these and other i
ssues relating to the likely success of using speech for ATM applicati
ons.