Kj. Noonan et al., DISTRACTION OSTEOGENESIS OF THE LOWER-EXTREMITY WITH USE OF MONOLATERAL EXTERNAL FIXATION - A STUDY OF 261 FEMORA AND TIBIAE, Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume, 80A(6), 1998, pp. 793-806
We reviewed the results of distraction osteogenesis of 114 femora and
147 tibiae that had been lengthened to treat a variety of diagnoses. T
he femora had been lengthened an average of eleven centimeters (range,
3.5 to 17.0 centimeters), or 48 per cent (range, 8 to 86 per cent) of
the original femoral length. The average total time for the treatment
of the femora (use of the fixator and any subsequent immobilization)
was 257 days (range, 105 to 420 days). There were 114 complications re
lated to the femoral lengthenings, which led to eighty-seven additiona
l operations. The tibiae were lengthened an average of nine centimeter
s (range, 3.0 to 15.6 centimeters), or 41 per cent (range, 9 to 100 pe
r cent) of the original tibial length. The average total time for the
treatment of the tibiae was 268 days (range, 110 to 497 days). There w
ere 196 complications related to the tibial lengthenings, which led to
219 additional operations. The Achilles tendon was lengthened during
or after seventy-three (50 per cent) of the tibial lengthenings. The f
emoral lengthenings that were performed to treat a limb-length discrep
ancy were associated with significantly higher rates of complications
overall (p = 0.010) and additional operations (p = 0.023) for each per
centage of length gained than those that were performed to treat achon
droplasia or another skeletal dysplasia, The femoral lengthenings that
were performed to treat short stature (of an endocrine or idiopathic
etiology) were also associated with higher rates of complications over
all and additional operations than those performed to treat skeletal d
ysplasias, but the rates were lower than those for lengthenings perfor
med to treat limb-length discrepancy, The rate of complications overal
l associated with femoral lengthening in patients who were fourteen ye
ars old or more was significantly higher than that associated with len
gthening in patients who were less than fourteen gears old (p = 0.047)
. Femoral lengthening through the metaphysis was associated with signi
ficantly higher rates of complications overall (p = 0.031) and additio
nal operations (p = 0.042) for each percentage of length gained than f
emoral lengthening through the diaphysis, The tibial lengthenings that
were performed to treat Turner syndrome and idiopathic short stature
were associated with significantly higher rates of complications overa
ll (p = 0.026) and additional operations (p = 0.003) for each percenta
ge of length gained than those performed to treat skeletal dysplasias.
The rate of joint-related problems (p = 0.044) and that of additional
operations (p = 0.053) after tibial lengthening in patients who were
fourteen years old or more were significantly higher than those rates
after tibial lengthening in patients who were less than fourteen years
old. The site of the tibial osteotomy did not affect the rate of comp
lications or additional operations. The femoral healing indices tin te
rms of both days per centimeter [p = 0.002] and days for each percenta
ge of length gained [p = 0.019]) were significantly higher in the pati
ents who were fourteen years old or more than in those who were less t
he fourteen years old. These values could not be used to predict an in
crease in the complications because of poor bone formation. The result
s of the present review suggest that the use of healing indices to gau
ge the final outcome of distraction osteogenesis is questionable; we w
ere unable to discern significance or clinical importance from appropr
iately adjusted values.