M. Bacardigascon et al., WITHIN-INDIVIDUAL AND BETWEEN-INDIVIDUAL VARIATION IN ENERGY AND MACRONUTRIENTS INTAKE BY ELDERLY WOMEN IN MEXICO, International journal of food sciences and nutrition, 49(4), 1998, pp. 289-293
Inter and intraindividual intake variance is a factor in evaluating th
e nutritional risk of individual subjects and in the assessment of nut
ritional risk in prospective studies. Several studies have shown that
inter and intraindividual variance depends on the population studied.
However, in Mexico there are no reported data of inter and intraindivi
dual variance in different high risk population groups. The purpose of
the present study was to determine the inter and intraindividual vari
ance in retired noninstitutionalized teachers over 60 years of age in
the city of Tijuana, BC, Mexico, Four-day dietary records were conduct
ed on 38 women between 60 and 94 years of age. All the participants we
re trained to weigh and register their food before and after each meal
. Two working days and two weekend days were randomly selected and inc
luded for each participant. The dietary registry was then checked by o
ne researcher and each subject to complete or adjust for any misunders
tanding. There were 152 days recorded, by Nutritionist IV software pro
gram, with the addition of different foods and meal combinations from
other composition tables, or estimating equivalent foods according to
their nutritional content. Inter and intraindividual variation coeffic
ients were calculated for energy and nutrient content (protein, carboh
ydrate, fat, cholesterol and fiber). The calculation of the estimated
number of days required to provide a true mean consumption for calorie
s, carbohydrate, fat, protein, cholesterol and dietary fiber was also
conducted. The intraindividual coefficient variation was found to be 2
6.9 for energy, 30.5 for carbohydrate, 39.4 protein, 43.3 fat, 49.0 fi
ber, and 62.0 for cholesterol. This study suggests that the number of
dietary days needed to estimate the mean intakes at the 95% confidence
level, within 30% of the true mean intake, is 3 days for energy, 4 da
ys for carbohydrate, 7 for protein, 8 for fat, 10 for fiber, and 16 da
ys for cholesterol.