Contradictory results concerning the effects of heavy liming have been
reported in South Africa for greenhouse studies on a variety of crops
using different liming materials. The current study addresses this co
ntroversy by investigating the consequences of overliming in maize and
wheat growth using calcium carbonate and calcium hydroxide as liming
materials, Growth media used include quartz sand and two acid oxisols
(high and medium buffered) to which phosphorus was applied before and
after the lime soil equilibration. The phase equilibria of soil phosph
orus were also investigated. Growth media, crop, liming material, and
manner of phosphorus fertilization all have a significant influence on
plant production during overliming studies and may account for the di
verse observations reported in the Literature. Soil chemistry and plan
t symptoms indicate that plant physiological effects induced by a more
reactive Lime source such as calcium hydroxide may play as prominent
a role in the outcome of overliming as nutrient deficiencies.