Nc. Estes et al., INADEQUATE DOCUMENTATION AND RESECTION FOR GASTRIC-CANCER IN THE UNITED-STATES - A PRELIMINARY-REPORT, The American surgeon, 64(7), 1998, pp. 680-685
Patients entered into Southwest Oncology Group gastric adjuvant protoc
ol INT 0016 (SWOG 9008) after a ''curative'' gastric resection were as
sessed to determine practice patterns of more than 300 surgeons nation
wide who performed ''curative'' gastric resections for 453 gastric can
cer patients. The most common gastric resection performed was distal i
n 256 patients, proximal in 118, and total in 79. Extragastric organs
resected were omentum (285), spleen (59), pancreas (18), and bowel (17
). The extent of lymphadenectomy as staged by Japanese rules was 246 (
54.2%) DO resections, 173 (38.1%) D1 resections, 28 (6.2%) D2 resectio
ns, and 7 (1.5%) D3 resections. Staging of the cancer was poorly docum
ented, with no statement made regarding the status of the primary canc
er in 6 per cent, liver in 10 per cent, lymph nodes in 17 per cent, an
d omentum in 17 per cent. The greater the lymph node clearance, the gr
eater the chance of resecting to a level of negative lymphatics, given
that 45 per cent of nodes were involved when 10 or less were removed,
whereas only 17 per cent were positive when more than 40 were cleared
. The lack of adequate clearance of lymph nodes and poor documentation
of tumor stage suggests that a more regimented surgical approach to t
his uncommon cancer is required.