F. Paye et al., PERCUTANEOUS ASPIRATION FOR BACTERIOLOGICAL STUDIES IN PATIENTS WITH NECROTIZING PANCREATITIS, British Journal of Surgery, 85(6), 1998, pp. 755-759
Background Percutaneous computed tomography (CT)-guided aspiration of
abdominal collections is performed in necrotizing pancreatitis to dete
ct infection of necrosis, which is an adverse prognostic factor and re
quires surgical drainage. However, in the case of sterile aspirates, t
he outcome and the optimum management are subject to debate. This stud
y examined the clinical and bacteriological outcome of patients with s
evere acute pancreatitis with initially sterile necrosis and assessed
the efficiency of percutaneous drainage in this setting.Methods Sevent
een patients hospitalized for necrotizing pancreatitis with a septic c
ourse underwent a preliminary sterile CT-guided aspiration. Eight pati
ents underwent simultaneous percutaneous drainage of the punctured col
lection. Supportive therapy was continued unless severe clinical deter
ioration or proven secondary infection of necrosis indicated the need
for necrosectomy and drainage. Results Secondary infection of necrosis
was observed in two patients of nine who had only fine-needle aspirat
ion cytology of the collection, and in seven of eight it was drained p
ercutaneously (P = 0.01). Only one patient drained percutaneously reco
vered without surgery. Surgical drainage was required in 12 patients.
The hospital mortality rate was 29 per cent and was not significantly
affected by the bacteriological status of necrosis. Conclusion Percuta
neous drainage of sterile collections predisposed to secondary infecti
on of the necrosis and did not cure the patients. A first sterile perc
utaneous aspiration did not predict a favourable course and surgery fr
equently remains necessary.