The existence of ''19-valence electron radicals'' has been a controver
sial issue in organometallic chemistry. The premise that photochemical
excitation of [W-2(CO)(10)](2-) in the presence of donor solvents or
phosphine ligands (L=THF, MeCN, 2-methyl THF, PEt3) leads to highly re
ducing 19e(-) L-W(CO)(5)(-.) radicals was investigated by laser transi
ent absorption (TA) spectroscopy in the UV-vis and IR regions and by e
lectron transfer kinetics studies. Infrared transient absorption measu
rements were found to be well suited to the [W-2(CO)(10)](2-) system.
The IR transient absorption spectrum at <1 mu s following the laser pu
lse in THF and MeCN is dominated by new IR absorptions at v(CO)>1960 c
m(-1). The LR transient absorption spectrum at >10 mu s following the
laser pulse is dominated by LR absorptions at v(CO)= 1860 and 1816 cm(
-1). The significant lowering of v(CO) energy in the first 10 mu s is
assigned to a 19e(-) solvent-W(CO)(5)(-.) (solvent=MeCN, THF) radical.
Rate constants for second order recombination (k(r)) of these radical
s are strongly solvent dependent. A homologous series of substituted b
enzophenone electron accepters (A) with E-1/2 (A/A(-.)) ranging from -
1.21 to -2.26 V vs. SCE were chosen to study the electron transfer che
mistry of the 19e- species in THF. Electron transfer rate constants (k
(st)) were found to ranee from 4 x 10(4) M-1 s(-1) for reduction of th
e least energetically favorable acceptor (cyclohexylphenyl-ketone, E-1
/2 = -2.26 V vs. SCE) up to 8 x 10(9) M-1 s(-1) for reduction of the m
ost energetically favorable acceptor (decaflurobenzophenone, E-1/2 = -
1.21 V VS SCE). The data were interpreted within the context of the M
arcus theory of electron transfer. The abnormally large total reorgani
zation energy, lambda=70 kcal mol(-1) and slow derived self-exchange r
ate constant, k(11) < 1 M-1 s(-1), reflect the large nuclear displacem
ents associated with the 18e(-)/19e(-) couple. It is concluded that al
though the 19e(-) solvent-W(CO)(5)(-.) radicals are thermodynamically
''super reducing agents'', capable in principle of single electron tra
nsfers to a wide variety of substrates, they are kinetically incompete
nt due to the enormous reorganization energy required to accommodate t
he nineteenth electron. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science S.A.