This paper considers the economic functions of contracting separately
for a portion of the insurance risk, offering both the payer's (i.e.,
employer 's) and the health plan's perspective. Four major forms of ca
rve outs are discussed: (1) payer specialty carve outs from all health
plans; (2) payer specialty carve outs from only indemnity and preferr
ed provider organization arrangements; (3) individual health plan carv
e outs to specialty vendors; and (4) group practice carve outs to spec
ialty organizations. The paper examines whether carving out care foste
rs the payer's goal of delivering reasonable healthcare efficiently, h
ow adverse selection affects the provision of healthcare, and the cost
s of providing this specialized care.