Aj. Brenner et al., INCREASED P16 EXPRESSION WITH FIRST SENESCENCE ARREST IN HUMAN MAMMARY EPITHELIAL-CELLS AND EXTENDED GROWTH CAPACITY WITH P16 INACTIVATION, Oncogene, 17(2), 1998, pp. 199-205
Aberrations affecting the tumor suppressor gene p16(INK4a) have been d
escribed for a variety of tumors. In breast cancer, approximately 50%
of tumors show low or lack p16 expression. While evidence provided by
some studies has implicated a possible role for p16 in normal replicat
ive senescence, other studies have suggested that the Rb, pathway thro
ugh which p16 functions, may not be involved in senescence control. Pr
eviously we observed that all immortal lines derived from normal mamma
ry epithelium which were analysed for p16 displayed inactivation of th
is gene through distinct mechanisms, supporting p16 inactivation as a
possible necessary event in escape from senescence. To further clarify
this issue, we have analysed p16 expression in a panel of normal fini
te lifespan human mammary epithelial cells (HMEC) from initial propaga
tion through growth arrest, using media which confer different replica
tive capacity. Approximately 10-25-fold increase in pld expression was
observed for all normal HMEC with initial onset of a senescence pheno
type following 15-25 population doublings in culture. These cells also
displayed expression of the senescence associated beta-galactosidase,
Interestingly, HMEC with additional long term replicative capacity (a
pproximately 80 population doublings) arose from these growth arrested
cultures, showing lack of pld expression. This extended growth capaci
ty appears to be associated with a methylation phenomenon since treatm
ent of these cells with the methylation inhibitor 5-aza-2-deoxycytidin
e resulted in growth arrest concurrent with reacquisition of p16 expre
ssion and senescence associated beta-galactosidase. Analysis of p21waf
1 expression revealed no change in expression during growth in vitro.
These results support p16(INK4a) as the 9p senescence gene and suggest
a role for p16 loss in the escape from initial onset of senescence an
d in acquisition of an extended life span of human mammary epithelial
cells.