Md. Dyar et al., INCLUSIVE CHEMICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF TOURMALINE - MOSSBAUER STUDY OF FE VALENCE AND SITE OCCUPANCY, The American mineralogist, 83(7-8), 1998, pp. 848-864
We report here the results of a series of inclusive chemical character
izations, including all elements except oxygen, for a suite of 54 tour
maline samples. A combination of analytical techniques was used to ana
lyze for major and light elements (electron microprobe), Fe3+ and Fe2 (Mossbauer spectroscopy), H (U extraction), and B, Li, and F (ion mic
roprobe, or SIMS). The B content of the tourmalines studied ranges fro
m 2.86 to 3.26 B per formula unit (pfu) with 31 anions; excess boron i
s believed to reside in the Si site. Li ranges from 0.0 to 1.44 Li pfu
and F contents are 0.0-0.91 pfu. H contents range from nearly anhydro
us up to 3.76 H pfu and do not correlate simply with Fe3+ content. Mos
sbauer results show that tourmaline exhibits the entire range of Fe3+/
Sigma Fe from 0.0-1.0. Fe2+ is represented in the spectra by three dou
blets, with occupancy in at least three distinct types of Y sites (wit
h different types of nearest and next nearest neighbors). Fe3+ was fou
nd in 26 of the 54 samples studied. Although Mossbauer data do not all
ow the distinction between Fe-[Y](3+) and Fe-[Z](3+) site occupancies
to be made, XRD data on these samples suggest that the majority of Fe3
+ is also in Y. Of the samples studied, Fe-[4](3+) occurs in nine; fiv
e of those were either olenite or uvite with extensive Na substitution
. A mixed valence doublet corresponding to delocalized electrons share
d between adjacent octahedra was observed in 14 of the samples studied
. Projection pursuit regression analysis shows that distribution of Fe
among doublets is a function (albeit a complex one) of bulk compositi
on of the tourmaline and supports the interpretation of doublets repre
senting different populations of neighbors. Variations in Fe3+/Fe2+ ra
tio cannot be directly related to variations in charge in any single s
ite of the structure. Fe3+/Fe2+ ratio is probably controlled by the pr
evailing oxidation state in the bull; rock assemblage, rather than by
any particular crystal chemical substitution.