Four test methods were investigated for their ability to discriminate
among various austenitic manganese hardfacing deposits as regards work
hardening capacity. The test methods are 1) Rockwell C testing in Bri
nell hardness impressions made with varying loads, 2) Meyer's Law appl
ied to Brinell impressions made with varying loads, 3) tensile testing
and 4) a newly devised drop-weight indentation test. Of these, only t
he drop-weight indentation test discriminated successfully among ordin
ary 14% Mn austenitic manganese steel, rich 20% Mn austenitic manganes
e steel and 15% Mn-15% Cr austenitic manganese steel. The two more hig
hly alloyed austenitic manganese compositions were found to offer high
er resistance to indentation than do the ordinary austenitic manganese
compositions. These results are being applied to high impact situatio
ns such as rail frogs.