Jc. Smart et Ka. Feldman, ACCENTUATION EFFECTS OF DISSIMILAR ACADEMIC DEPARTMENTS - AN APPLICATION AND EXPLORATION OF HOLLANDS-THEORY, Research in higher education, 39(4), 1998, pp. 385-418
This longitudinal study of college students found accentuation of init
ial group differences among academic subenvironments for Artistic abil
ities of both male and female students and for Enterprising abilities
of male students. It also showed that male and female students in Arti
stic subenvironments-for whom Artistic abilities and interests were ea
ch of the two gender groups' initially prominent characteristic-increa
sed still further in score on the Artistic abilities and interest scal
e over four years of college; and parallel results were found for male
students in Enterprising subenvironments in terms of Enterprising abi
lities and interests. Moreover, both male and female students initiall
y high on Artistic and Enterprising abilities and interests ''gained''
more on these attributes if they entered congruent academic subenviro
nments (Artistic and Enterprising subenvironments, respectively) than
if they entered any of the other subenvironments. Whereas these findin
gs support Holland's theory, other data (primarily for Investigative a
nd Social abilities and interests of students) were either less suppor
tive or unsupportive of Holland's theory. Some implications of these r
esults are discussed.