T. Coplan et al., EARLY LANGUAGE-DEVELOPMENT IN CHILDREN EXPOSED TO OR INFECTED WITH HUMAN-IMMUNODEFICIENCY-VIRUS, Pediatrics (Evanston), 102(1), 1998, pp. 81-84
Objectives. To compare language development in infants and young child
ren with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection to language deve
lopment in children who had been exposed to HIV but were uninfected, a
nd (among subjects with HIV infection) to compare language development
with cognitive and neurologic status. Design. Prospective evaluation
of language development in infected and in exposed but uninfected infa
nts and young children. Setting. Pediatric Infectious Disease Clinic,
State University of New York-Health Science Center at Syracuse. Subjec
ts. Nine infants and young children infected with HIV and 69 seroposit
ive but uninfected infants and children, age 6 weeks to 45 months. Res
ults. Mean Early Language Milestone Scale, 2nd edition (ELM-2) Global
Language scores were significantly lower for subjects with HIV infecti
on, compared with uninfected subjects (89.3 vs 96.2, Mann-Whitney U te
st). The proportion of subjects scoring >2 SD below the mean on the EL
M-2 on at least one occasion also was significantly greater for subjec
ts with HIV infection, compared with uninfected subjects (4 of 9 infec
ted subjects, but only 5 of 69 uninfected subjects; Fisher's exact tes
t). Seven of the 9 subjects with HIV infection manifested deterioratio
n of language function. Four manifested unremitting deterioration; onl
y 1 of these 4 demonstrated unequivocal abnormality on neurologic exam
ination. Three subjects with HIV infection and language deterioration
showed improvement in language almost immediately after the initiation
of antiretroviral drug treatment Magnetic resonance imaging or comput
ed tomography of the brain were performed in 6 of 7 infected subjects
with language deterioration, and findings were normal in all 6. ELM-2
Global Language sealed scores showed good agreement with the Bayley Me
ntal Developmental Index or the McCarthy Global Cognitive Index (r = 0
.70). Language deterioration, or improvement in language after initiat
ion of drug therapy, coincided with or preceded changes in global cogn
itive function, at times by intervals of up to 12 months. Conclusions.
Language deterioration occurs commonly in infants and young children
with HIV infection, is seen frequently in the absence of abnormalities
on neurologic examination or central nervous system imaging, and may
precede evidence of deterioration in global cognitive ability. Periodi
c assessment of language development should be added to the developmen
tal monitoring of infants and young children with HIV infection as a m
eans of monitoring disease progression and the efficacy of drug treatm
ent.