Y. Gazitt et al., BCL-2 OVEREXPRESSION IS ASSOCIATED WITH RESISTANCE TO DEXAMETHASONE, BUT NOT MELPHALAN, IN MULTIPLE-MYELOMA CELLS, International journal of oncology, 13(2), 1998, pp. 397-405
Multiple myeloma (MM) is an incurable disease despite an initial respo
nse-rate of >60% with conventional or high-dose chemotherapy. Glucocor
ticosteroids such as dexamethasone (DEX) and alkylating agents such as
melphalan (MEL) are capable of inducing complete responses (CR) in >5
0% of MM patients, however, resistance to these drugs develop rapidly,
in >90% of patients, within 2 years of treatment. The exact mechanism
of resistance to these drugs is not known. We investigated the mechan
ism of resistance to DEX and MEL. In particular, we investigated the r
ole of bcl-2 in development of resistance to these two drugs. We teste
d the role of bcl-2 by transfecting 2 low bcl-2-expressing myeloma cel
l lines, ARP-1 and 8226, with a bcl-2 expression vector and compared t
he effects of DEX and MEL on apoptosis, cell cycle distribution and th
e levels of proapoptotic (bax) and antiapoptotic (bcl-2, bclx) protein
s. The results indicate that the two drugs act by a different mechanis
m with respect to all the parameters tested. While DEX-induced apoptos
is was dependent on the level of bcl-2 expression, MEL-induced apoptos
is was independent of bcl-2 levels. Treatment with DEX of the low bcl-
2-expressing cells (DEX-sensitive) resulted in a rapid apoptosis from
all phases of the cell cycle. In contrast, treatment with MEL blocked
the cells in late-S/G2 phase of the cell cycle and caused substantial
apoptosis, regardless of bcl-2 expression. Major differences between D
EX and MEL were also observed with respect to their effects on the lev
els of bcl-2 and p53. Whereas DEX induced an early (day 1) downregulat
ion of bcl-2 (only in the cells with low bcl-2), treatment with MEL di
d not affect bcl-2 levels. The levels of bclx and bar remained unchang
ed following treatment with either MEL or DEX. These results, taken to
gether, suggest that the two drugs target different cellular component
s and induce apoptosis by different pathways, and that resistance to D
EX is associated with low levels of bcl-2, whereas resistance to MEL i
s independent of bcl-2, and therefore, in vivo resistance to MEL, obse
rved in MM patients, might involve other mechanisms rather than bcl-2.