An important question for the evolution of host specialization in inse
ct herbivores concerns why evolutionary changes in host choice mainly
affect specificity in some species and the rank order of preference in
others. A qualitative model is developed in which evolutionary change
in specificity (and conservatism of the rank order of preference) res
ults from functional and genetic integration between life history and
behavioral traits. Conversely, another model proposes that a lack of s
uch functional and genetic integration allows the expression of a pote
ntial tradeoff between the number of host used and the ability to dete
ct or recognize them, which ultimately favors evolutionarily labile ra
nk order of preference. Quantitative and population genetic approaches
are appropriate to test both models.