D. Dean et al., AVERAGE AFRICAN-AMERICAN 3-DIMENSIONAL COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY SKULL IMAGES - THE POTENTIAL CLINICAL IMPORTANCE OF ETHNICITY AND SEX, The Journal of craniofacial surgery, 9(4), 1998, pp. 348-358
The production of average 'normative' three-dimensional (3D) computed
tomography surface images of the bony skull has only recently been exp
lored. The authors wish to determine the effect of using sex- and ethn
icity-specific adult average 3D skull images for comparisons with pati
ent images at various stages of craniofacial surgical management (i.e.
, diagnosis, treatment planning, prosthetic design, image-guided opera
tive procedures, and outcomes assessment). Craniofacial surgical recon
struction for abnormal patterns of development, cancer resection, or t
rauma are most likely to benefit from these comparisons. To morphometr
ically test the significance of separating normative 3D skull data by
sex: and ethnicity, the authors collected 52 3D, anatomical landmarks
from 3D computed tomography scans of dry skulls of 20 Americans of Eur
opean ethnicity and 20 Americans of primarily African (i.e., primarily
African and some European) ethnicity. A Procrustes-based morphometric
analysis of shape detects 1.2 times as much interethnic variance as i
ntersex variance. The African American sample presents 4.2% more dolic
hocephaly, wider orbits, flatter nasal area, larger gnathic anatomy, a
nd more procumbent dentition. Pooling the sexes across both groups, it
is seen that men tend to have less bulbous crania, more protruding br
ews, noses, and masticatory muscle attachments, and relatively less pr
otrusive palettes and anterior mandibles. Despite a small sample size
(N = 40), the authors' results are statistically significant (P simila
r to 0.001 overall) for both of the main factors, sex and ethnicity, s
eparately.