S. Sakane et al., CONTINUUM CORRECTIONS TO THE POLARIZATION AND THERMODYNAMIC PROPERTIES OF EWALD SUM SIMULATIONS FOR IONS AND ION-PAIRS AT INFINITE DILUTION, JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY B, 102(29), 1998, pp. 5673-5682
Ewald sum simulations of the solvation thermodynamics of charged solut
es employ an unphysical uniform neutralizing background charge to ensu
re convergence of the periodic lattice sum. Continuum corrections to t
he solvation free energy, entropy, and volume of single ions and ion p
airs for the effect of the neutralizing background and periodic bounda
ry conditions at finite cell size are derived in order to allow effici
ent calculations of the ionic properties at infinite dilution. The der
ivation presented in this paper shows the physical origin of the effec
ts and can be easily extended to multiple charge sites. Corrections ar
e small for high dielectric constant solvents but become increasingly
important as the ion size is increased, the dielectric constant is dec
reased, or the unit cell size is decreased. An alternative way of calc
ulating the thermodynamic properties from Ewald sum simulations is pro
posed for which the corrections are small for low dielectric constant
solvents. Tests for low and high dielectric constant water show that,
after the appropriate continuum corrections are applied, the free ener
gy of charging an ion using Ewald sum simulations agrees with the resu
lts for potential truncation simulations and spherical boundary simula
tions (when corrected for truncation effects). The corrected free ener
gy of hydration is not sensitive to the system size even for low diele
ctric constants. The continuum model correctly predicts that Ewald sum
simulations yield a solvent polarization at large distance from an io
n that is smaller than the polarization of a truly infinite system.