White-crowned sparrow (Zonotrichia leucophrys) song varies geographica
lly, often forming local 'dialects' in sedentary and short-distance mi
gratory subspecies. In playback experiments males and females can dist
inguish this variation. Gambel's white-crowned sparrow (Z. l. gambelii
) is a long-distance migrant that breeds across subarctic Canada and A
laska. Previous studies identified a wide degree of song variation wit
hin local populations of this subspecies. I compared songs recorded in
Alaska and Churchill, Manitoba, and found significant differences in
acoustic structure. As in other subspecies, the most prominent differe
nces occurred in the terminal trill portion of the song. In a playback
experiment to territorial males at Churchill, males gave equivalent s
trong responses to both Alaska and local gambelii song, significantly
weaker responses to mountain white-crowned sparrow (Z. l. oriantha) so
ng, and the weakest responses to heterospecific song. I describe a mod
el of song recognition in which 'dialect recognition' is a component o
f species recognition. I conclude that as a consequence of differences
in the timing of song learning, the subspecies of white-crowned sparr
ow may differ in the acoustic features that they attend to in song rec
ognition. The diversity of song types at a local level within gambelii
populations may interfere with recognizing song differences between p
opulations.