The validity and utility of applying results of home range analysis to
long-term wildlife management objectives depends on the assumption th
at populations remain relatively faithful to such ranges over time, bu
t such an assumption is rarely investigated analytically. We evaluated
the home range Fidelity of elk (Cervus elaphus) in 3 populations in s
outhcentral Montana and northwestern Wyoming via comparison of home ra
nge use, size, and boundaries in 2 different time periods, 1979-82 and
1986-91, using 265 locations of 15 elk and 971 locations of 23 elk. R
ange use changed significantly in 2 of 3 populations between time peri
ods (P < 0.01), but total size of home range (95% minimum convex polyg
on) changed in only 1 population (P < 0.05). Significant seasonal chan
ges in elevational use accompanied changes in range boundaries and use
in every season. Distances between radiocollared elk located simultan
eously decreased in all seasons in 2 populations (P < 0.05), suggestin
g increasing herd cohesion and social stability. Changes in range use
in differ ent time periods consistently tended to increase spatial sep
aration of populations of elk and to reduce densities of elk. Range bo
undaries of populations were fluid over time, suggesting boundaries an
d use of home ranges of larger populations of elk should be systematic
ally reinvestigated at intervals of less than or equal to 10 years if
accurate estimation of these parameters is important to management.