Objective: To test both the genetic and acquired hypotheses for the et
iology of hippocampal sclerosis (HS) by studying with optimized and qu
antitative MRI three monozygous (MZ) twin pairs in which the index twi
n had temporal lobe epilepsy and HS. Background: There is conflicting
evidence in the literature regarding whether PIS is genetic or acquire
d prenatally, perinatally, or as a consequence of prolonged childhood
seizures, Methods: We compared three MZ pairs with 30 age-matched cont
rol subjects who had no history of a neurologic disorder; we also used
the twins as matched samples to assess subtle differences between the
affected and the unaffected twins. Results: All of the affected twins
had prolonged seizures with fever in early childhood, which stood out
as the unique factor common to all affected twins and was absent in a
ll the unaffected twins. HS was present in all affected twins but was
absent in the unaffected twin on visual, volumetric, and T2 relaxometr
y criteria. Comparison of the affected twin with the co-twin revealed
that intracranial volume ipsilateral to the HS was relatively small in
two of three affected twins. Conclusions: The absence of HS in the un
affected twin is strong evidence against a genetic hypothesis for PIS.
Neither perinatal problems nor birth order were factors in determinin
g the presence of HS. This twin study supports the notion of WS as an
acquired lesion secondary to prolonged seizures in early childhood and
suggests that regional abnormalities of intracranial volume are assoc
iated with HS.