T. Asami et al., EVOLUTION OF MIRROR IMAGES BY SEXUALLY ASYMMETRIC MATING-BEHAVIOR IN HERMAPHRODITIC SNAILS, The American naturalist, 152(2), 1998, pp. 225-236
Directionally asymmetric animals generally exhibit no variation in han
dedness of whole-body architecture. In contrast, reversed chirality in
both coil and entire anatomy has frequently evolved in snails. We dem
onstrate a nonrandom pattern and deterministic process of chiral evolu
tion, as predicted by the following hypothesis. Bimodal shell shapes a
re associated with discrete mating behaviors in hermaphroditic pulmona
tes. Flat-shelled species mate reciprocally, face-to-face. This sexual
symmetry prevents interchiral mating because genitalia exposed by a s
inistral on its left side cannot be joined with those exposed by a dex
tral on its right. Thus, selection against the chiral minority, result
ing from mating disadvantage, stabilizes chiral monomorphism. Tall-she
lled species mate nonreciprocally the ''male'' copulates by mounting t
he ''female's'' shell, mutually aligned in the same direction. This se
xual asymmetry permits interchiral copulation with small behavioral ad
justments. Therefore, the positive frequency-dependent selection is re
laxed, and reversal alleles persist longer in populations of tall-shel
led species. We verified both the assumption and the prediction of thi
s hypothesis: significantly lower interchiral mating success in a low-
spired species and higher chiral evolution rate ill high-spired taxa.
Sexual asymmetry is the key to understanding the accelerated chiral ev
olution in high-spired pulmonates.