Interspecific nest parasitism is surprisingly rare in birds given the
potential advantages for the parasite of exploiting the parental care
of other species. One possibility is that chicks will not thrive with
the parental care and food of heterospecifics. I simulated parasitism
in nonparasitic congeners by switching eggs between nests of three spe
cies of titmice (great tit Parus major, blue tit Parus caeruleus, and
coal tit Pants ater). The experiment showed that compatibility of pare
ntal care was not a constraint preventing parasitism. I also used the
model system to compare fitness consequences of inter- and intraspecif
ic nest parasitism, addressing the problem of which form is ancestral.
Fledging success (body mass, survival) was higher when an egg was add
ed.to the nest of a smaller species than to the nest of a conspecific
and also higher when the parasitic chick hatched early rather than lat
e relative to host chicks. This suggests that interspecific nest paras
itism may not require a stage of intraspecific nest parasitism before
evolving but may start from a larger species directly exploiting the p
arental care of a smaller species or a species with shorter incubation
period directly exploiting a species with longer incubation period.