L. Vasseur et al., CLOVER AND CRESS AS INDICATOR SPECIES OF IMPACTS FROM LIMED SEWAGE-SLUDGE AND LANDFILL WASTE-WATER LAND APPLICATION, Science of the total environment, 217(3), 1998, pp. 231-239
This study evaluated the performance of cress and clover as bioindicat
ors to evaluate the impact of limed sewage sludge and landfill wastewa
ter application on soil. The use of these two species, and the subsequ
ent parameters measured, were also compared for their effectiveness in
evaluating potential effects. Sewage sludge was added to the soil at
a rate of 23 mg ha(-1) and also at twice this dose. Wastewater was add
ed at a level of 2 and 10% of the soil volume. Germination rate, heigh
t increase per week and final dry biomass were measured for both speci
es. Heavy metal (Cd, Pb, Fe, Cu, Ni, and Zn) concentration was determi
ned only for the shoot and root of clover. In general, the results sho
wed that, compared to the control, the overall performance improved fo
r plants exposed to both treatments. However, plants appeared to respo
nd better to the wastewater addition than the sewage sludge amendment.
The germination rate as well as other traits indicate that clover may
be more sensitive to these fertilizers than cress. The lime addition
did not appear to influence growth, nor heavy metal accumulation in cl
over. There were major differences in heavy metal accumulation in the
root vs. shoot of clover. Hence, the concentrations of Cd, Cu, Fe, Zn,
and Pb did not vary in the shoots of the plants under either treatmen
ts. The concentrations of the heavy metals in the roots however, great
ly varied according to the type of metals. The concentrations of these
metals appeared to increase with the increase of the addition treatme
nts. The results suggest that for both species, the levels of fertiliz
ers used in the present study were below the toxicity levels. Since th
e types of soils and the doses of fertilizers influence the rate of he
avy metal absorption and their effects on plants, methods for rapid ev
aluation/monitoring as well as the types of indicators used should be
explored as in the present study. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All r
ights reserved.