Tb. Kinraide et al., AL3-CA2+ INTERACTIONS IN ALUMINUM RHIZOTOXICITY .2. EVALUATING THE CA2+-DISPLACEMENT HYPOTHESIS(), Planta, 192(1), 1994, pp. 104-109
Several mineral rhizotoxicities, including those induced by Al3+, H+,
and Na+, can be relieved by elevated Ca2+ in the rooting medium. This
leads to the hypothesis that the toxic cations displace Ca2+ from tran
sport channels or surface ligands that must be occupied by Ca2+ in ord
er for root elongation to occur. In this study with wheat (Triticum ae
stivum. L.) seedlings, we have determined, in the case of Al3+, that (
i) Ca2+, Mg2+, and Sr2+ are equally ameliorative, (ii) that root elong
ation does not increase as Ca2+ replaces Mg2+ or Sr2+ in the rooting m
edia, and (iii) that rhizotoxicity is a function solely of Al3+ activi
ty at the root-cell membrane surface as computed by a Gouy-Chapman-Ste
rn model. The rhizotoxicity was indifferent to the computed membrane-s
urface Ca2+ activity. The rhizotoxicity induced by high levels of tris
(ethylenediamine)cobaltic ion (TEC3+), in contrast to Al3+, was specif
ically relieved by Ca2+ at the membrane surface. The rhizotoxicity ind
uced by H+ exhibited a weak specific response to Ca2+ at the membrane
surface. We conclude that the Ca2+-displacement hypothesis fails in th
e case of Al3+ rhizotoxicity and that amelioration by cations (includi
ng monovalent cations) occurs because of decreased membrane-surface ne
gativity and the consequent decrease in the membrane-surface activity
of Al3+. However, TEC3+, but not Al3+, may be toxic because it inhibit
s Ca2+ uptake. The nature of the specific H+-Ca2+ interaction is uncer
tain.