Arguing that models of the evolution of coal production pay insufficie
nt attention to the economic, political and social environment externa
l to the mine, this article analyses changes in the Upper Silesian coa
lmining industry during communism and after within a top-down, bottom-
up framework. Three spatial scales are recognized: macro, meso and mic
ro. Prior to the soft revolution of 1989, the Soviet model of heavy in
dustrialization and international trading conditions were important is
sues, while at the national scale the government structured the indust
ry and gave miners a special place in Polish society. Coal production
could also be related to political vicissitudes. At the local scale th
e spatial characteristics of the industry strongly correlated with geo
logy, bottom-up forces being weak. The international collapse of commu
nism fundamentally changed the fortunes of the industry, bur despite t
he free market, the government continues to exercise considerable infl
uence. Bottom-up forces are now more important, the collieries having
a degree of autonomy, while the devolution of considerable political p
ower to the counties has led to the enforcement of environmental prote
ction regulations.