Am. Gadomski et al., ASSESSMENT OF RESPIRATORY RATE AND CHEST INDRAWING IN CHILDREN WITH ARI BY PRIMARY-CARE PHYSICIANS IN EGYPT, Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 71(5), 1993, pp. 523-527
In a baseline study for training purposes, two indicators of acute res
piratory infections (the respiratory rate (RR) and chest indrawing) we
re assessed by Ministry of Health physicians in Egypt using a WHO test
videotape. Chest indrawing, as defined by the WHO Acute Respiratory I
nfections (ARI) programme, was not widely recognized by current health
personnel. Viewing a WHO training videotape led to significantly more
correct assessments of chest indrawing compared with a group that had
not viewed this videotape. The accuracy of using a timer versus a wat
ch, and a 30-second versus 60-second counting interval was also evalua
ted. Rates counted over 60 seconds were more accurate than 30-second c
ounts although the difference between them was not clinically signific
ant. Counting of rates using timers with audible cues was comparable t
o using watches with second hands. Careful training of primary health
workers in the assessment of RR and chest indrawing is essential if th
ese clinical findings are to be used as reliable indicators in pneumon
ia treatment algorithms.