Mt. Mentis et Wn. Ellery, ENVIRONMENTAL-EFFECTS OF MINING COASTAL DUNES - CONJECTURES AND REFUTATIONS, South African journal of science, 94(5), 1998, pp. 215-222
The conjectured effects of mining coastal dunes in northeast South Afr
ica were that mining would cause irreparable damage, homogenise soils,
destroy litter and reduce biodiversity that rehabilitation would not
restore. It was further conjectured that succession to forest climax t
akes centuries, that post-mining vegetation recovery is a function of
distance from the seashore where refugia exist and that ecologists can
not predict local succession. The conjectures were tested using 44 unm
ined and 62 mined sample plots. Mined and unmined soils could not be d
istinguished reliably. The depth of the organic layer at the soil surf
ace was a function of time since disturbance and soil density. Species
richness did not differ between mined and unmined land. The upper asy
mptote of species richness was projected to be reached in 28 to 40 yea
rs post-mining, and convergence on forest climax species composition i
n 54 to 70 years. Distance from the seashore was confounded with other
variables that better explained vegetation recovery. The key multiple
regressions developed to test the conjectures accounted individually
for 45% or more of the variation in the dependent variables, and had o
verall P values from <0.01 to <0.001. Randomly assigned subsets of the
database yielded statistically indistinguishable patterns, implying t
hat inferences were robust.