Rw. Bibby et al., RELIGION AND IDENTITY - THE CANADIAN, AMERICAN, AND BRAZILIAN CASES, International journal of comparative sociology, 39(2), 1998, pp. 237-250
Changing cultural conditions in three quite different settings-a highl
y industrialized Canada, an increasingly post-industrial United States
, and an industrializing Brazil-have led many observes to assert that
the religious markets in the three countries are fairly open. However,
an examination of affiliation patterns reveals that the traditionally
strong religious groups in the three societies are succeeding in main
taining monopolies. Identification with the long-established mainline
churches remains both very stable and high, despite the activities and
claims of religious competitors. Religious affiliation continues to b
e largely inherited, complete with important social, psychological, an
d emotional associations. Nevertheless, general cultural specializatio
n has contributed to an accelerated inclination on the part of Canadia
ns, Americans, and Brazilians to look to religious groups for highly s
pecific services. These include programs with spiritual and social jus
tice emphases, and rites of passage pertaining to birth, marriage, and
death. Religious groups have responded to such market demands by expa
nding their religious menus and, in the process, largely neutralizing
the offerings of religious competitors. The result is very tight speci
alized religious markets in all three countries. Identification prevai
ls, but the related impact of religion at the level of the individual
is extremely specific and limited.