Ch. Flamme et al., LONG-TERM FOLLOW-UP RESULTS AFTER RESECTION ARTHROPLASTY OF THE GREATTOE, Zeitschrift fur Orthopadie und Ihre Grenzgebiete, 136(3), 1998, pp. 250-254
Introduction: Resection arthroplasty of the first metatarsal-phalangea
l joint is a wellknown operation for hallux valgus. The follow-up resu
lts more than 17 years after arthroplasty are reported and discussed.
Material and methods: Between 1971 and 1980, 335 arthroplasties were p
erformed on 205 patients. The only indication for arthroplasty of the
great toe was hallux valgus. The technique of arthroplasty was accordi
ng to Keller-Brandes. 102 patients were reexamined clinically and radi
ographically, after 17.6 years on average. Results: Questionnaire asse
ssment revealed a significantly prolonged walking distance and 70% of
the patients were painfree at the time of investigation, whereas 67% s
uffered from severe pain before operation. Clinical evaluation showed
diminished wheightbearing of the great toe during walking and a reduce
d range of motion of the partial-resectcd first metatarsal-phalangeal
joint. Radiographically the shortening of the phalangeal bone of 37% w
as evident as expected. Hallux-valgus-angle was 23 degrees at the time
of investigation and 34 degrees preoperatively in the mean. Discussio
n: The high rate of hallux valgus relapse, especially due to a high in
termetatarsal angle demonstrate unsatisfactory longterm results by the
Keller-Brandes operation. We now recommend this operation for older p
atients and a differentiated approach according to the clinical and ra
diographical situation for younger patients.