In this study, we examine how experience at the level of the organizat
ion, the population, andthe related group affects the failure of Manha
ttan hotels. We find organizational experience has a U-shaped effect o
n failure; that organizations enjoy reduced failure as a function of p
opulation experience before their founding, but not after; and that re
lated organizations provide experience that lowers failure, but it mat
ters whether their experience is local or non-local, and if it was acq
uired before or after the relationship was established. These results
indicate both the difficulty of applying different types of experience
to reduce the risk of organizational failure, and the relevance of ex
perience for the evolution of organizational populations.