Sk. Skagen et al., COMPARATIVE USE OF RIPARIAN CORRIDORS AND GASES BY MIGRATING BIRDS INSOUTHEAST ARIZONA, Conservation biology, 12(4), 1998, pp. 896-909
The relative importance of cottonwood-willow riparian corridors and is
olated oases to land birds migrating across southeastern Arizona was e
valuated during four spring migrations, 1989 to 1994, based on pattern
s of species richness, relative abundance, density, and body condition
of birds. We surveyed birds in 13 study sites ranging in size and con
nectivity from small isolated patches to extensive riparian forest, sa
mpled vegetation and insects, and captured birds in mistnets. The cont
inuous band of riparian vegetation along the San Pedro River does not
appear to be functioning as a corridor for many migrating species, alt
hough it may for a few, namely Yellow-breasted Chats (Icteria virens),
Summer Tanagers (Piranga rubra), and Northern Rough-winged Swallows (
Steldigopteryx serripennis), which account for fewer than 10% of the i
ndividuals migrating through the area. Small, isolated oases hosted mo
re avian species than the corridor sites, and the relative abundances
of most migrating birds did not differ between sites relative to size-
connectivity. There were few differences in between-year variability i
n the relative abundances of migrating birds between corridor and oasi
s sites. Between-year variability decreased with overall abundance of
species and was greater for species with breeding ranges that centered
north of 50 degrees N latitude. Body condition of birds did not diffe
r relative to the size-connectivity of the capture site, but individua
ls of species with more northerly breeding ranges had more body fat th
an species that breed nearby. Peak migration densities of several bird
species far exceeded breeding densities reported for the San Pedro Ri
ver, suggesting that large components of these species were en route m
igrants. Peak densities of Yellow Warblers (Dendroica petechia) reache
d 48.0 birds, ha, of Wilson's Warblers (Wilsonia pusilla) 33.7 birds/h
a, and of Yellow-rumped Warblers (D. coronata) 30.1 birds/ha. Riparian
vegetation is limited in extent in the vicinity of our study sites, c
overing less than 1% of the landscape. We conclude that all riparian p
atches in southeastern Arizona are important as stopover sites to en r
oute migrants regardless of their size and degree of isolation or conn
ectivity. In light of potential habitat limitation, the protection of
both small, disjunct riparian patches and extensive riverine tracts in
western landscapes is imperative.