Y. Oda et al., GIANT-CELL TUMOR OF BONE - ONCOLOGICAL AND FUNCTIONAL RESULTS OF LONG-TERM FOLLOW-UP, Japanese Journal of Clinical Oncology, 28(5), 1998, pp. 323-328
Background: Giant cell tumor (GCT) of bone is a rare and unpredictable
lesion. Its standard treatment has ranged from surgical curettage to
wide resection and varying oncological and functional results have bee
n reported. Methods: A retrospective review of 47 patients (17 males a
nd 30 females) with GCT of bone was performed to evaluate the oncologi
cal and functional results. The patients were followed up for at least
5 years. The average age of the patients was 32 years (range 15-66 ye
ars). The tumor sites were distal femur in 15 cases, proximal tibia in
10, distal radius in five, spinal column in four, proximal femur in t
hree, proximal humerus in three, proximal fibula in two, pelvis in two
and others in three. Enneking's surgical stages were Stage 1 in three
, Stage 2 in 34 and Stage 3 in 10 cases. In these 47 patients, 80 surg
ical procedures were performed. Results: The rate of local recurrence
was 75% in the 28 patients undergoing intralesional excision, 50% in t
hose receiving excision and curettage and 0% in those receiving wide r
esection. Although there was no statistical significance, surgical sta
ges tended to be correlated with the local recurrence rate (Stage 1, 0
%; Stage 2, 53%; Stage 3, 70%). Functional evaluation was performed ac
cording to the most recent system of the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society
. Functional results of the patients with extremity tumors were 28.2 (
average) in those undergoing intralesional excision, 30 (average) in t
hose receiving excision and curettage and 27.1 (average) in those rece
iving wide resection. Functional results were significantly correlated
with the initial surgical stages (Stage 1, 30; Stage 2, 27.5; Stage 3
, 24.4; Kruskal-Wallis test, P = 0.016), Conclusions: To preserve good
function of the extremities and avoid local recurrence, we consider t
hat intralesional excision with adjunctive therapy such as phenol caut
erization should be employed for the treatment of benign GCT of bone.