A NEW PERSPECTIVE ON THE RACE DEBATE

Authors
Citation
Ro. Andreasen, A NEW PERSPECTIVE ON THE RACE DEBATE, British journal for the philosophy of science, 49(2), 1998, pp. 199-225
Citations number
82
Categorie Soggetti
History & Philosophy of Sciences","History & Philosophy of Sciences","History & Philosophy of Sciences
ISSN journal
00070882
Volume
49
Issue
2
Year of publication
1998
Pages
199 - 225
Database
ISI
SICI code
0007-0882(1998)49:2<199:ANPOTR>2.0.ZU;2-A
Abstract
In the ongoing debate concerning the nature of human racial categories , there is a trend to reject the biological reality of race in favour of the view that races are social constructs. At work here is the assu mption that biological reality and social constructivism are incompati ble. I oppose the trend and the assumption by arguing that cladism, in conjunction with current work in human evolution, provides a new way to define race biologically. Defining race in this way makes sense whe n compared to the developments in other areas of systematic biology, w here shared history has largely replaced morphological similarity as t he foundation of a natural biological classification. Surprisingly, it turns out that cladistic races and social constructivism are compatib le. I discuss a number of lessons about the way human biological races have been conceptualized.