Pw. Nolan et al., FRUITS WITHOUT LABOR - THE IMPLICATIONS OF NIETZSCHE,FRIEDRICH IDEAS FOR THE CARING PROFESSIONS, Journal of advanced nursing, 28(2), 1998, pp. 251-259
Seldom is the work of philosophers invoked by health professionals whe
n examining aspects of care from a philosophical perspective. Instead,
students of health care, especially nurses, have been introduced to '
philosophies' which are often superficially examined and poorly unders
tood. This practice fails to develop in students an appreciation of th
e work of philosophers or to acquire the art of critical thinking. The
introduction of models and theories of nursing in the past three deca
des has alerted nurses to the importance of possessing critical skills
in order to identify sound theory and implement good practice. This p
aper goes beyond mere philosophising and examines aspects of mental he
alth care from the perspectives of one of nineteenth century Europe's
most notable philosophers, Friedrich Nietzsche. It argues that underst
anding his work can enhance one's ability to reflect on nursing practi
ce, as well as bringing a new dimension to how we analyse 'mental heal
th' problems. His work provides many insights into how we can improve
our understanding of the effect of mental illness and mental health ca
re on the individual, and how we conceptualise the process of care. Th
is paper provides an overview of his life's work, his impact on the hi
story of ideas and develops some of the more provocative implications
of his work for mental health care.