Objective: To determine the most effective method of short-term middle
ear aeration in patients unable to tolerate hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) t
herapy. Study Design: Prospective study comparing two methods of short
-term tympanostomy in each patient. Methods: Seventeen adult patients
were referred for management of barotitis and inability to tolerate hy
perbaric oxygen therapy (HBO), Each patient underwent CO2 laser tympan
ostomy on the right ear and tympanostomy with T-tube placement in the
left ear. The tube was removed on completion of HBO, Patients were ask
ed to rate pain and their satisfaction with each method of tympanostom
y using a visual analog scale. Otorrhea, persistent perforation, recur
rent barotitis, hearing loss, and otalgia occurring during the study p
eriod were documented, Results: Laser tympanostomy was associated with
a significantly lower incidence of otorrhea but was attended by re cu
rrent barotitis in four of 16 patients. Laser tympanostomy was perceiv
ed as being less painful and was rated higher in overall satisfaction.
Conclusions: Laser tympanostomy is an effective method for management
of barotitis in patients unable to tolerate HBO, Otorrhea is signific
antly reduced, although a risk of recurrent barotitis exists if the la
ser perforation closes prior to completion of HBO, Both methods of sho
rt-term tympanostomy reduce complications when compared with a retrosp
ective cohort.