Cy. Ko et al., WHAT IS THE BEST METHOD OF SURGICAL TRAINING - A REPORT OF AMERICA LEADING SENIOR SURGEONS, Archives of surgery, 133(8), 1998, pp. 900-903
Objectives: To characterize the career choices and developments made b
y leading senior surgeons in this country and to examine hypotheticall
y whether application of a short tracking program would have hindered
their career decisions. Design: A survey pertaining to each surgeon's
career, decisions, and opinions concerning surgical training. Setting
and Participants: Senior surgeons of regional and national surgical so
cieties. Main Outcome Measure: Survey responses. Results: A total of 3
52 surveys (41.4%) were received. Respondents answered that the most c
ommon reasons for choosing a specialty were role models or mentors (56
%), research (51%), and available patient population (23%). The 2 most
common stages in a career at which the respondents became interested
in a specialty, or an area of expertise, were at the junior residency
level (when the specialty was chosen) and at the assistant professor l
evel (when a more specific topic within the specialty was chosen). The
most common stage at which the group believed they acquired their exp
ertise was also at the assistant professor level. Seventy-one percent
of respondents believed broad training was superior to a short trackin
g system, although none had participated in shortened surgical trainin
g. Conclusions: Most leading senior surgeons in this country still bel
ieve that broad surgical training is superior and should be maintained
. Because career specialties in this surveyed group were generally cho
sen in early residency, a hypothetical application of the short tracki
ng system would have still allowed for these important decisions to be
made. Also, it seems likely that specialty and career development wou
ld not have been hindered because ''expertization'' mostly occurred af
ter training was completed. Regardless of training method, a role mode
l or mentor seems most important in career choices and developments.