Rm. Callaway, COMPETITION AND FACILITATION ON ELEVATION GRADIENTS IN SUB-ALPINE FORESTS OF THE NORTHERN ROCKY-MOUNTAINS, USA, Oikos, 82(3), 1998, pp. 561-573
The relative importance of competition and facilitation has been hypot
hesized to change with variation in abiotic conditions. 1 examined the
relative importance of competition and facilitation along elevation g
radients in the northern Rocky Mountains where Pinus albicaulis and Ab
ies lasiocarpa dominate the overstory. Al lower elevations and in more
sheltered sites, A. lasiocarpa seedlings, saplings, and trees were no
t spatially associated with mature P. albicaulis, whereas at high-elev
ation sites along exposed ridges near timberline A. lasiocarpa were hi
ghly aggregated around mature P, albicaulis. I also compared growth ra
tes of A. lasiocarpa trees before and after the death of adjacent P. a
lbicaulis to growth rates of A. lasiocarpa in the same years but adjac
ent to living trees. Ln the Bitterroot Mts. a. lasiocarpa responded po
sitively to the death of adjacent P. albicaulis at low-elevation sites
(7% increase), but negatively at high-elevation sites (24% decrease).
This suggests that facilitation was more important at timberline site
s characterized by abiotic extremes and competition was more important
in more moderate abiotic conditions. At high-elevation sites in both
mountain ranges, large A. lasiocarpa were 2-4 times more aggregated wi
th P. albicaulis than A. lasiocarpa seedlings. At the high-elevation s
ite in the Bitterroots, growth rates of large A. lasiocarpa were signi
ficantly lower in open microsites than when trees were adjacent to eit
her living or dead P. albicaulis. In contrast, growth rates of small s
aplings did not differ among these microsites. Stronger facilitative e
ffects on mature trees than on seedlings or saplings may develop becau
se the winter snowpack protects small A. lasiocarpa from blowing ice a
nd snow. After trees grow above the snowpack shelter From large P, alb
icaulis may be crucial. These results emphasize the importance of stud
ying interspecific interactions over a range of conditions; in these f
orests both positive and negative interactions occur between A. lasioc
arpa and P. albicaulis, but their relative importance depends on abiot
ic conditions and plant life history stage.