S. Monarca et al., MUTAGENICITY OF EXTRACTS OF LAKE DRINKING-WATER TREATED WITH DIFFERENT DISINFECTANTS IN BACTERIAL AND PLANT-TESTS, Water research (Oxford), 32(9), 1998, pp. 2689-2695
Raw water and drinking water samples collected from five treatment pla
nts supplied by a northern Italian lake in two periods of the year (su
mmer and winter) were studied for their mutagenicity. The water sample
s were concentrated on silica C-18 cartridges and the adsorbates were
tested at increasing doses with a bacterial short-term mutagenicity te
st (Ames test with Salmonella typhimurium TA98 and TA100 strains), whi
ch reveals the gene-mutation-inducing ability of pollutants, and with
a plant genotoxicity bioassay (Tradescantia/micronucleus test), which
determines clastogenicity (chromosome-breaking ability). Raw water sam
ples from all treatment plants were found to contain bacterial direct-
acting mutagens detectable mainly with TA98 strain. The analyses of dr
inking water samples after water treatment showed some interesting res
ults: TA98 mutagenicity was reduced when ozone was used together with
chlorine dioxide, but TA100 mutagenicity was increased, though only in
the summer sample; mutagenicity detectable with both strains was alwa
ys reduced after chlorine dioxide disinfection; on the contrary, in al
l treatment plants using NaClO TA98 mutagenicity of winter samples inc
reased. Raw lake water induced a high number of micronuclei in the Tra
descantia/micronucleus lest, showing a strong clastogenicity. This act
ivity was higher in the NaClO-treated samples, and lower with the othe
r disinfectants. Therefore, disinfection of lake water with ozone and/
or chlorine dioxide seems to be a suitable alternative to the use of N
aClO for controlling the formation of nonvolatile mutagens. The concen
tration method coupled with the two mutagenicity tests was found to be
a simple, rapid and relatively inexpensive system for monitoring trea
tment plants and studying the influence of different disinfection syst
ems on water mutagenicity. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights r
eserved.