Sr. Lowenstein et al., BEHAVIORAL RISK-FACTORS IN EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT PATIENTS - A MULTISITE SURVEY, Academic emergency medicine, 5(8), 1998, pp. 781-787
Background: Many people rely on EDs for routine health care. Often, ho
wever, screening and counseling for health risks are not provided. Obj
ective: To determine prevalence rates of chronic disease and injury ri
sk factors and access to routine health care in a random sample of ED
patients in 3 cities. Methods: A prospective survey was conducted at 3
hospital EDs in Akron, OH, Boston, MA, and Denver, CO. A modified ver
sion of the national Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance Survey was ad
ministered by trained researchers to a convenience sample of non-criti
cally ill patients during randomly selected shifts. Results: Of 1,143
eligible patients, 923 (81%) agreed to participate. Their mean age was
39 (range = 17-96) years. Most were female (58%), white (60%), and un
married (68%). Thirty-eight percent had no access to primary care. Inj
ury-prone behaviors were prevalent: 53% of the respondents did not wea
r seat belts regularly; 15% had no working smoke detector; 3% kept loa
ded, unlocked handguns in their homes; 11% had attempted suicide; 23%
had a positive CAGE screen for alcoholism; 3% had operated a motor veh
icle in the preceding month while alcohol-intoxicated; and 11% had rid
den in an automobile with an intoxicated driver. Cancer and chronic di
sease risks were also common: 48% smoked; 16% had not received a blood
pressure check in the preceding year; and 4% reported unsafe sexual p
ractices. Among women aged > 50 years, 42% had not received a Pap test
in the prior 2 years and 14% had never had mammography. Many prevalen
ce rates and access to care varied among the 3 sites. However, for mos
t risk factors, prevalence rates did not differ in patients with and w
ithout access to primary health care. Conclusions: ED patients have hi
gh rates of injury and chronic disease risks, and many have no other s
ource of routine health care. Research is needed to determine whether
ED-based programs, designed to reduce injury and chronic disease risks
, are feasible and cost-effective.