Forest productivity typically declines after reaching a peak early in
stand development. Historically this pattern was attributed to constan
t or declining stand photosynthesis and increasing stand respiration,
but this explanation has been largely invalidated by field measurement
s and modeling. Production in older stands might decline as a result o
f declining soil nutrient supply. To test this idea, we examined patte
rns of productivity and nitrogen (N) supply and use in four age classe
s of lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta Dougl, ex. Loud.) ecosystems in so
utheastern Wyoming. Aboveground net primary production (ANPP) increase
d from 2200 kg ha(-1) yr(-1) at age 30 to 4600 kg ha(-1) yr(-1) at age
50,then declined to 2000 kg ha(-1) yr(-1) at age 200, Soil N supply (
indexed with ion exchange resin bags) was highest in the 30-yr-old sit
es, but showed no further pattern with age in older sites. The ratio o
f ANPP to the supply of N rose sharply from age 30 to age 50, and then
declined slowly. The ratio of ANPP to the N actually taken up was hig
h for the three youngest age classes, but declined substantially in th
e old-growth (200 yr) site. We conclude that the low ANPP of the old-g
rowth stands was probably not driven by changes in stand nutrition; th
e decline in efficiency of N use indicates some other factor probably
constrains productivity of old-growth stands.