A paradox has been posed that challenges the second law of thermodynam
ics in a plasma blackbody environment [D. P. Sheehan, Phys. Plasmas 2,
1893 (1995)]. Laboratory experiments testing critical aspects of the
paradox have supported theoretical predictions and have failed to reso
lve the paradox in favor of the second law. In this article, the parad
ox is sharpened and expanded in scope by identifying the crux of the p
aradox and the general requirements for second law violation. It is fo
und that for an electrically conducting probe immersed in a blackbody
plasma and connected to ground through a load, the general requirement
for second law violation is V(f)not equal 0, where V-f is the plasma
floating potential. This requirement can be met by many natural and ma
nmade plasmas. (C) 1998 American Institute of Physics. [S1070-664X(98)
03206-6]