THE INFLUENCE OF INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATION ON THE IMPACT OF RESEARCH RESULTS - SOME SIMPLE MATHEMATICAL CONSIDERATIONS CONCERNING THE ROLE OF SELF-CITATIONS
Afj. Vanraan, THE INFLUENCE OF INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATION ON THE IMPACT OF RESEARCH RESULTS - SOME SIMPLE MATHEMATICAL CONSIDERATIONS CONCERNING THE ROLE OF SELF-CITATIONS, Scientometrics, 42(3), 1998, pp. 423-428
There is an ongoing discussion on the influence of international colla
boration on impact as measured by citation-based indicators. Collabora
tion generally involves more authors than 'no collaboration' work and
it is obvious that the phenomenon of self-citation will be stronger (t
here are more authors to cite themselves). Thus it can be seen as an i
mportant amplifier' of measured impact. Although this effect is certai
nly possible and already demonstrated recently, it should not be consi
dered as the only or even major explanation of higher impact in the co
mparison between 'no collaboration' and international collaboration. U
sing data of an extensive bibliometric study of astronomical research
in the Netherlands, we prove that higher rates of self-citation in int
ernational collaboration do not play any significant role as 'impact a
mplifier'. The central point is that proper impact measurement must in
volve corrections for self-citations.