Aims: Awareness of hereditary breast and ovarian cancer in both the ge
neral public and the medical profession is increasing. Individuals who
may be at risk on the basis of a family history are requesting risk d
etermination and appropriate management in a variety of settings. Risk
determination relies largely on pedigree analysis and epidemiological
data. Methods: We describe five individuals presenting in the family
cancer or genetic counselling clinic where a factitious family or pers
onal history led to erroneous risk estimation. Common factors in these
families are a history of benign breast disease, poor communication w
ithin families, long survival with early onset or bilateral disease, a
lack of detailed knowledge of the illness and treatment in close rela
tives and inconsistencies in the history in repeated consultations.