Kf. Arcaro et al., LACK OF SYNERGY BY MIXTURES OF WEAKLY ESTROGENIC HYDROXYLATED POLYCHLORINATED-BIPHENYLS AND PESTICIDES, Environmental health perspectives, 106, 1998, pp. 1041-1046
We examined the estrogenicity of binary mixtures of the hydroxylated p
olychlorinated biphenyls (OHPCBs) 2,4,6-trichloro-4'-biphenylol (2,4,6
-TCB-4'-OH) and 2,3,4,5,-tetrachloro-4'-biphenylol and the pesticides
endosulfan and dieldrin. The OHPCBs and pesticides were tested in both
the MCF-7 focus assay and a competitive estrogen-receptor binding ass
ay. Although the individual OHPCBs were estrogenic in both assays, the
re was no synergy when they were combined at various concentrations as
equimolar mixtures. Of the pesticides, only endosulfan was estrogenic
. Its weak estrogenicity was seen only in the MCF-7 focus assay at the
highest concentration tested-10 CIM There was no synergy of the equim
olar mixture of pesticides. To determine whether OHPCBs might respond
synergistically when combined with the natural estrogen 17 beta-estrad
iol (E-2) we tested various concentrations of 2,4,6-TCB-4'-OH in the M
CF-7 focus assay in combination with physiologically relevant concentr
ations of E-2. There was no synergy between 2,4,6-TCB-4'-OH and E-2. P
retreatment for 3 or 7 days with 2,4,6-TCB-4'-OH had no effect on subs
equent foci induced by a combination of 2,4,6-TCB-4'-OH and E-2. Altho
ugh our results showing no synergy between the pesticides or the OHPCB
s are in contrast to a recent report that binary mixtures of these sam
e compounds produce synergistic responses in estrogen-sensitive assays
, they are in agreement with the results from other assays showing a l
ack of synergy. Considering all results, it appears that synergy of th
ese weakly estrogenic compounds acting through the estrogen receptor i
s unlikely.