L. Garand et S. Nadon, HIGH-RESOLUTION SATELLITE ANALYSIS AND MODEL EVALUATION OF CLOUDS ANDRADIATION OVER THE MACKENZIE BASIN USING AVHRR DATA, Journal of climate, 11(8), 1998, pp. 1976-1996
Both the issues of high-resolution satellite analysis and model evalua
tion for a region centered on the Arctic Circle (60 degrees-75 degrees
N) are addressed. Model cloud fraction, cloud height; and outgoing ra
diation are compared to corresponding satellite observations using a m
odel-to-satellite approach (calculated radiances from model state). Th
e dataset consists of forecasts run at 15-km resolution up to;30 h and
nearly coincident Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) im
agery during the Beaufort and Arctic Storm Experiment over the Mackenz
ie Basin for a monthly period in the fall of 1994. A cloud detection a
lgorithm is designed for day and night application using the 11-mu cha
nnel of AVHRR along with available information on atmospheric and grou
nd temperatures. The satellite and model estimates of cloud fraction a
re also compared to observations at 20 ground stations. A significant
result of the validation is that the model has a higher frequency of l
ow cloud tops and a lower frequency of midlevel cloud tops than the ob
servations. On a monthly basis, the model 11-mu outgoing brightness te
mperature (TB) is consequently higher than observed by about 4.4 K at
all forecast times, which corresponds to a deficit of 760 m in mean cl
oud-top height and about 10 W m(-2) in outgoing Aux at the top of the
atmosphere. Possible errors in the parameterization of ice or water cl
oud emissivity are evaluated but ruled out as the dominant cause for t
he warm TB bias in the model. Rather, the problem is attributed to low
clouds being trapped in the boundary layer, whereas high clouds appea
r to be reasonably well modeled. The role of thin ice clouds is furthe
r evaluated by comparing distributions of observed and modeled Il-p mi
nus 12-mu TB differences, DIF45 (channel 4 minus channel 5). The relat
ionship between the true height of the clouds and the effective height
observed by satellite is modeled from forecast outputs as a function
of DIF45. The quality of daily estimates is evaluated from time series
at various locations. The time series shows that there was a marked d
rop in DIF45 during the month, which is attributed to a decrease in th
e occurrence of cirrus clouds. Finally. the diurnal cycle of TB and cl
oud fraction is found to be relatively large with average monthly 0600
-1800 UTC TB differences of both signs of the order of 4-8 K in broad
sectors and cloud fraction differences of 10%-30%. Where low clouds pr
evail, the cloud fraction tends to decrease at night and TB increases.
Overall, model-observation differences are dominated by differences i
n the vertical distribution of clouds. A reduction of this effect impl
ies a modification of the ''preferred'' model climatology in terms of
its vertical distribution of humidity and cloud water.